(703) 260-9444 MAKE AN APPOINTMENT

Root Collar Excavation: The Tree Service Most Homeowners Have Never Heard Of

Root collar excavation is the systematic removal of any soil or mulch piled around the base of a tree trunk, so an arborist can find and correct girdling roots and other hidden problems. 

Despite being unfamiliar to many homeowners, root collar excavation is a time-tested arboricultural technique that allows for the diagnosis and treatment of many belowground problems. And because girdling roots often cause trees to decline within five to 10 years, the value of root collar excavation is clear.   

Below, we’ll explain how root collars become buried, the warning signs root collar issues cause, and the steps involved in a root collar excavation. 

Quick Check: Is Your Tree’s Root Flare Buried?

If you can answer “yes” to any of the following questions, your tree’s root flare may be buried: 

  • Does the trunk go straight into the ground like a telephone pole, with no widening at the base?    
  • Is mulch piled against the bark, or deeper than 4 inches?  
  • Can you see a root crossing over or wrapping around the base of the trunk? 
  • Is the canopy thinning, with small or yellowing leaves or dieback at the branch tips?  

What Is a Root Collar & Why Are Problems with Them So Often Overlooked?

A tree’s root collar (also known as the root flare, trunk flare, or root crown) is where the trunk widens and meets the first structural roots. The bark covering the flare is like the bark on the trunk, rather than the bark covering the roots. This means that it has evolved to be in contact with air, rather than soil or mulch. 

When buried, the root flare bark can decay or suffer damage. It may also develop girdling or adventitious roots. 

Unfortunately, these issues are often overlooked, as they occur below ground level and typically only cause generic symptoms. Accordingly, homeowners often treat these trees by applying fertilizer or pest treatments — neither of which will address the issue. 

But when an ISA Certified Arborist performs a root collar excavation, they can literally uncover these problems and take the steps needed to address them.  

mulch volcano around tree trunk rtec treecare

How a Tree’s Root Collar Gets Buried

Root collars typically become buried in one of three ways, with the responsibility falling on the homeowner, landscaping crew, nursery, construction crew, or a sloppy tree care team. 

  • The tree is planted too deeply, with the root flare positioned below ground level. This can happen because of poor planting technique, but it’s especially common when the tree was already planted too deeply by the nursery. 
  • Mulch is deliberately or inadvertently piled around the trunk. Known by arborists as “volcano mulching,” this harmful practice should be avoided. Mulch should be applied over the root zone, but it must be kept several inches from the trunk. 
  • The grade near a tree is changed during construction or trenching work. Even when trees are planted and mulched correctly, they may develop root flare problems if large amounts of soil are left near the trunk. 

Proper Technique Prevents Root Flare Problems

To avoid problems with buried root collars, you’ll want to:

  • Remove excess soil around balled-and-burlapped trees and ensure the root flare is visible. 
  • Plant trees so that the root flare is approximately 1 to 2 inches above grade. 
  • Spread mulch across the root zone out to the drip line but keep it away from the trunk.
  • Don’t dump dirt produced by construction activity around a tree’s base. 

The Problems Buried Root Collars Cause for Trees

Trees with buried root collars may suffer from a variety of problems, caused by both the improper conditions and the trees’ response to those conditions. 

For example, the constant moisture caused by mulch or soil around a tree base will foster the development of decay near the base. It can also encourage insect activity and promote some tree diseases. Excessive soil or mulch can also starve a tree’s roots of oxygen. 

Some of these things, such as the moisture near the trunk, can encourage the development of girdling roots, which wrap around the trunk or structural roots, starving the tree of water and critical nutrients. Similarly, poor oxygen levels can cause trees to develop shallow surface roots. 

There’s even empirical evidence that demonstrates how problematic it can be to plant trees too deeply. A 2006 study titled “Effects of Planting Depth on Landscape Tree Survival and Girdling Root Formation” documented the extent of girdling roots for trees planted at different depths. 

Red Maple Planting DepthShare of Trunk Circumference Encircled by Girdling Roots 3 Years After Planting
At grade (flare at soil line)14%
6 inches too deep48%
12 inches too deep71%

Root Collar Problems by Species

Any tree can suffer from girdling roots when planted or cared for improperly. In fact, the University of Minnesota reports that they’ve been documented in at least 56 species in North America. However, these problems tend to be especially common in a few trees, including:

  • Maples (Acer spp.), particularly Norway maple (Acer platanoides)
  • Lindens (Tilia spp.)
  • Ashes (Fraxinus spp.)
  • Crabapples (Malus spp.)
  • Hackberries (Celtis spp.) 

Signs Your Tree Needs a Root Collar Inspection

Buried root collars often go unnoticed by homeowners, but they can lead to a number of symptoms including:  

  • The lack of a visible flare, creating a telephone-pole-like appearance   
  • Yellowing foliage, smaller-than-normal leaves, and leaf scorch
  • Branch dieback, often starting in the upper crown
  • Cracking or peeling bark near the base
  • Cankers at the base of the trunk  
  • New growth that leafs out in spring and dies back during the summer  

None of these symptoms necessarily indicates the presence of a root collar problem, but they are all serious enough to warrant an inspection by an ISA Certified Arborist. 

Find Out If Your Tree Is Suffering from Root Collar Issues

Root zone problems rarely go away on their own. Many become worse over time, continually reducing the number of treatment and mitigation options available. That’s why it’s important to be proactive and have your tree’s root collar inspected anytime you suspect there’s a problem. 

The ISA Certified Arborists at RTEC Treecare have extensive experience performing root collar excavations, identifying any problems they find, and laying out plans for correcting any issues present. 

With a 30-year history caring for trees across the Greater D.C. area, we understand the local trees and soil conditions, as well as the science-backed techniques that often prove helpful in these situations. Make an appointment today to have your tree’s root collar inspected before a girdling root does lasting damage. 

What Happens During a Root Collar Excavation

arborist performing root collar excavation rtec treecare

A root collar excavation involves two key steps: exposing the root collar and examining the conditions the work reveals. 

Exposing the Root Flare with an Air Spade

The first step in a root collar excavation involves the removal of soil, mulch, gravel, and other materials through the use of a specialized tool called an air spade. 

The air spade is essentially a nozzle that’s connected to a large air compressor, which allows the arborist to blow away the material around the roots. By using compressed air, the arborist doesn’t need to use shovels or other hand tools, which may damage the trunk or roots. 

The arborist will usually work until the soil is at the level of the original grade and the first structural roots are visible. In some cases, the work can continue to expose a larger percentage of the root system, if necessary. 

Assessing What the Excavation Uncovers

Once the soil and other materials have been removed, the arborist can begin examining the root flare and identifying any problems that are now visible. 

For example, the arborist may note the presence of one or more girdling roots. Depending on the size, placement, and extent of these roots, he or she may cut the roots to prevent further damage, though some roots may need to be left in place, having grown too large to be safely removed. 

The arborist will also look for things like basal decay, cankers, or cracks, as well as metal basket material, twine, or burlap left behind from the planting process.  

Root Collar Excavation: Frequently Asked Questions

Learning that your tree may be suffering from hidden, belowground problems can be unsettling and raise a number of questions. We’ll try to help by answering some of the most common ones our clients have about root collar excavation.  

How much does root collar excavation cost?

The cost of root collar excavation varies based on the tree’s size, the depth to which the root flare is buried, and the mitigation actions needed. Contact us now to make an appointment and get a tailored estimate for your root collar excavation project. 

Can I excavate my tree’s root flare myself?

Homeowners can excavate the root flare of very small trees by hand, though it is critical that you use great care to avoid harming the roots. 

Is root collar excavation safe for the tree?

When performed with an air spade by an ISA Certified Arborist, root collar excavation is generally considered safe. By using compressed air, root disturbance can be kept to a minimum, and by giving the arborist the chance to visualize and correct root system issues, the benefits usually outweigh the risks. 

How deep should mulch be around a tree?

Mulch should be spread no thicker than 4 inches above ground level to avoid oxygen deprivation for the roots. More importantly, keep the mulch away from the root flare and trunk, because mulch against the trunk can cause girdling roots and decay. 

Will cutting a girdling root hurt my tree?

Cutting a girdling root can hurt a tree in some cases, but certified arborists generally follow guidelines that help minimize these risks. For example, girdling roots that only cover one-half of the trunk’s circumference or less can often be cut and removed without significantly harming the tree. 

How long can a tree survive with girdling roots?

Trees with girdling roots often decline over a period of five to 10 years. The fact that death often occurs over an extended time period is part of the reason that belowground issues are often missed. 

Is root collar excavation the same as air spading?

No, root collar excavation refers to the removal of material around the root collar; air spading is the technique by which a root collar excavation takes place. However, an air spade tool can also be used for other jobs, such as soil aeration. 

Have an ISA Certified Arborist Check Your Tree’s Root Flare

While root collar problems may occur out of sight, they shouldn’t be out of mind. 

Left unchecked, cankers, cracks, decay, and girdling roots can not only compromise your tree’s health but its stability too. That’s why it’s often wise to have a root collar excavation performed for trees showing symptoms of an underground problem — particularly if the tree holds significant value or grows in a high-traffic area. 

contact for root collar excavation rtec treecare

The ISA Certified Arborists at RTEC Treecare would be happy to carry out a root collar excavation for your trees. We’ll expose the flare with an air spade, remove any girdling roots that can safely come out and recommend follow-up care. 

Make an appointment today to keep your tree healthy and stable for years to come.  

Sources & References

Share the post:

Table of Contents

Schedule A Consultation

Have any questions? Our team is waiting to hear from you!
Meet The Author

Our Latest Posts & Updates

Join Our Weekly Newsletter

Your privacy is important to us. View our Privacy Policy for details. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Call The RTEC Emergency Hotline!

Before You Go...

Feel free to leave your contact information on our online form.  A consultation is always free, and it’s the first step towards finding a solution for your trees!

RTEC Treecare Local City Hall